More Website Traffic Won’t Fix Your Marketing
More visitors, more clicks, more impressions and higher rankings are often presented as signs that marketing is working. The problem is that traffic by itself does not generate revenue. Customers generate revenue. Increasing traffic will not magically generate more phone calls, form submissions or new customers if there’s a disconnect in the conversion loop.
More Traffic Doesn’t Always Mean More Customers
A website with 500 visitors per month and 40 leads is performing far better than a website with 5,000 visitors per month and 20 leads. The number of visitors matters much less than what those visitors actually do once they arrive.
Conversion rates can vary significantly by industry and by the type of purchase a customer is making. If each job is worth several thousand dollars or more, customers will often research extensively, visit multiple websites and take time before making a decision.
In those industries, lower traffic-to-lead conversion rates are normal because customers spend more time researching before contacting a company. On the other hand, businesses that offer lower-cost or urgent services may see much higher conversion rates because customers are ready to make a decision quickly.
Traffic numbers and conversion rates should always be viewed in the context of the type of service being offered and the typical buying process.
Regardless of the vertical, marketing should be measured by outcomes such as leads, new customers and revenue, not just by how many people visited the website. Traffic is only useful if the visitors are potential customers who are likely to hire the business.
Traffic Intent Matters More Than Traffic Volume
Not all searches have the same intent. Someone searching for general information is very different from someone searching for a company to hire.
For example, a person searching for general information, definitions or how-to instructions may be researching a topic, working on a school project or trying to solve a problem themselves. A person searching for a specific service in a specific city is much more likely to be looking for a company to hire.
Websites often gain large amounts of traffic from informational content, but that traffic does not always turn into leads. Meanwhile, service pages that target high-intent searches may get far fewer visitors but produce far more phone calls and form submissions.
This is becoming even more important as AI search tools and answer engines change how informational searches work. Many informational queries are now answered directly on the search results page or within AI-generated summaries, which means informational content may generate less website traffic than it did in the past.
As a result, high-intent searches and service-related searches are becoming even more important for businesses that invest in their website as a lead generation tool.
The bottom line is that a smaller number of visitors who are actively looking to hire someone is far more valuable than a large number of visitors who are just looking for information.
Sometimes the Problem Is the Wrong Audience
Another common issue is attracting the wrong type of visitors altogether. A website may be getting traffic from people who are not likely to become customers, including:
- People looking for do-it-yourself instructions
- Students researching a topic
- Vendors trying to sell products or services
- Job seekers looking for employment
- People outside the company’s service area
- Competitors researching the business
- People looking only for prices but not ready to hire anyone
In these situations, the issue is targeting and messaging, and increased volume will not solve it.
More Traffic Can Make Marketing Look Better Than It Is
One of the biggest problems with focusing too much on traffic is that it can give business owners a false sense of effectiveness. This is why it’s so important to have an internal method of tracking lead volume in your CRM or through another system.
Make your marketer defend their results if they claim traffic is increasing and progress is being made, but you can see from your own numbers that:
- Phone calls stay the same
- Form submissions stay the same
- Close rates stay the same
- Revenue stays the same
This type of scenario is the bane of good marketers. Business owners don’t like being told their marketing is performing well despite receiving no additional work or revenue.
Sometimes there are valid contributing factors that are influencing conversion or lead generation (like economic factors, industry changes or poor call handling), but rosy reporting could also just be spin from your account manager.
The Goal Is Not Traffic, It’s Customers
Instead of focusing primarily on traffic, businesses should pay closer attention to metrics that are directly connected to revenue and growth. More useful marketing metrics often include:
- Phone calls
- Form submissions
- Qualified leads
- Cost per lead
- Cost per new customer
- Close rate
- Revenue generated from marketing
- Customer acquisition cost
- Repeat customers and referrals
Website traffic is not the end goal of marketing. It is just one step in the process. The real goal is to generate leads, new customers and revenue.
Instead of focusing on increasing traffic, ask your marketer the more important question: are the right people visiting the website, and are they becoming customers?
Get an Honest Assessment
If you’re looking for an honest assessment, contact REV77 for a free digital audit.
